Arrow icon
Back to Insights

Domestication: How a Corporation Changes Everything

What’s a Rich Text element?

The rich text element allows you to create and format headings, paragraphs, blockquotes, images, and video all in one place instead of having to add and format them individually. Just double-click and easily create content.

  • Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet
  • Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet
  1. Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet
  2. Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet

Static and dynamic content editing

A rich text element can be used with static or dynamic content. For static content, just drop it into any page and begin editing. For dynamic content, add a rich text field to any collection and then connect a rich text element to that field in the settings panel. Voila!

How to customize formatting for each rich text

Headings, paragraphs, blockquotes, figures, images, and figure captions can all be styled after a class is added to the rich text element using the "When inside of" nested selector system.

What can nonprofit leaders do when they find the laws or administration of their organization’s state of formation are unfavorable, or continued legal compliance in that state is no longer practical? Corporations are creatures of state law – their legal existence derives from the laws of the state where they were incorporated. Given the fundamental nature of this relationship, it would seem that a corporation is forever stuck under the legal regime of the state in which it was formed, even if it undertakes no activities in that state and has no reason to maintain any ties with it. That is not necessarily a problem, since many organizations keep their original state of formation and then register to do business in one or more other states based on specific activities and applicable state requirements. But for those who seek a different path, fortunately, “a man can change his stars” (à la Heath Ledger’s memorable line in A Knight’s Tale), and a corporation can in fact change its state of incorporation.

State of Formation

Most nonprofits start from a visioning process, with a founder or group of willing leaders developing goals to accomplish a specific nonprofit mission. These plans form into written articles of incorporation (or other corporate charter), setting forth the corporate name, the corporation’s purpose statement, and other key formation information about where the nonprofit will form and under which Act. The articles are then filed with a state secretary of state's office or respective state agency. At that point, the nonprofit corporation comes into existence as a legal entity, under the laws of that state. Generally, nonprofit founders choose to form their organization in the state where key leadership or programs are located, but sometimes strategic reasons warrant incorporating in another state.

When a nonprofit corporation is created in a particular state, it must be organized under that state's laws – typically a nonprofit or nonstock corporation act. The state's nonprofit corporation statute thus generally governs its corporate structure and internal affairs, often in general terms with default language (e.g., "unless the bylaws provide otherwise"). Among other matters, the statute often addresses corporate name requirements, board meeting notices, voting, fiduciary duties, the rights of members, and other significant governance and transactional items such as mergers or dissolutions. This state statutory framework continues to govern the nonprofit as long as it remains incorporated in the state, even if circumstances change and the nonprofit carries out its operations elsewhere.

This is true even when other states' laws may also apply based on where the nonprofit operates, employs staff, holds property, or solicits contributions. For example, a nonprofit incorporated in Illinois, whose headquarters and operations are in Virginia and subject to Virginia law, must still comply with the Illinois Nonprofit Act and file annual reports with the Illinois Secretary of State. That nonprofit would thus would face legal compliance requirements in both Illinois (the state of its incorporation) and in Virginia (the state of its operations). Such additional legal compliance may be merely incremental or more daunting, depending on the states involved and the nonprofit’s scope of operations.

Considering Domestication

Most states now offer a pathway for nonprofit corporations to “domesticate” into or out of that state. “Domestication” (or sometimes called “conversion”) is the state statutory process by which a corporation changes its jurisdiction of incorporation while continuing as the same legal entity. By changing its state of formation, a nonprofit throws off the requirements of the state statute under which it was formed and chooses to come under the authority of a new state’s corporate statute. In other words, the fundamental nature and legal basis for the very existence of the corporation is changed, with the stroke of a proverbial pen.

Whether a nonprofit should domesticate or not turns on a number of governance, compliance, and operational considerations – all to be carefully evaluated with legal counsel, and not to be undertaken lightly. As noted above, many corporations begin in one state and then expand into other states by simply filing and maintaining “foreign business” registrations in those states. For some nonprofits, maintaining these registrations is a more viable path than changing the state of incorporation. For others, domestication may better align with the organization’s long-term goals and mission. For nonprofit leaders considering such a move, the following general considerations provide a useful starting point.

As a foundational matter, keep in mind that for a nonprofit to domesticate in a new state, the laws of both states must permit domestication. It is thus critical to evaluate both states' laws. Additionally, the nonprofit's board should consider how the destination state's statutory rules will impact the corporation. State nonprofit statutes vary across a variety of fields, including number of directors, required officers, member approval rights, and meeting and notice requirements. The board should also evaluate any required notices to or approvals from a state attorney general, court, or other regulator.

As a side note, particularly for when state law does not allow domestication, a potential alternative may instead be to develop and transition to a new nonprofit corporation. With this approach, the new nonprofit entity could carry on the original entity’s mission, receive the original entity’s funds and other assets, take over its activities, and assume its liabilities too. The original entity can then be later dissolved, effectively no longer needed because the new entity – in the desired new state - is now fully operational. (See also our W&O blog article on dissolution.) This alternative approach involves its own significant costs, however, such as for a new EIN, application for IRS tax-exemption, the new corporation’s development, and transitional aspects (e.g., HR, contracts, banking, donor relations). Further, to appropriately dissolve the initial entity, it would be subject to a comprehensive corporate wind-up process, including any final compliance reporting, de-registrations, and other essential dissolution steps. Before embarking in this process, it is important to consider the full picture; this process may only be beneficial in certain situations.

The Domestication Process

Although the details differ by state, the corporate domestication process generally involves developing a written plan, obtaining certain required corporate approvals, and completing the filings required by both states. A formal plan of domestication typically identifies the nonprofit, its existing and proposed jurisdictions of formation, and any terms and conditions. Depending on applicable law, the plan may also need to include proposed articles of incorporation, revised bylaws, and provisions addressing membership rights. Even when not required as part of the plan, the corporation’s articles and bylaws should be reviewed for compliance with the destination state's statute. The plan of domestication should also address continuity of the nonprofit's existence, assets, liabilities, and operations, as well as applicable tax-exemption requirements.

The plan must then be approved in accordance with applicable law and the nonprofit's articles and bylaws. Some states require approval procedures similar to those required for a corporate merger. These steps may include appropriate notice, board approval, and approval by voting members or others with reserved approval rights. These approvals should be reflected in carefully prepared written corporate resolutions, retained with the nonprofit's meeting minutes. Upon obtaining these approvals, the nonprofit must complete the required filings with the Secretary of State or comparable filing office in its home and destination state.

Depending on the states involved, these filings may take the form of articles of domestication, a certificate of domestication, or a statement of domestication or conversion. They commonly identify the nonprofit, its current and new jurisdictions, and the required approvals. The filings may also require amended or restated articles of incorporation, certificates of good standing, or other supporting documents. Filing fees, effective-date rules, and signature requirements for domestication vary from state to state.

Life in a New State

Following a successful corporate domestication, the updated nonprofit entity will be both organized under and subject to the law of its new jurisdiction. Applicable statutes commonly preserve ownership of property and responsibility for existing liabilities without a separate transfer. Notably, domestication does not erase debts, claims, or restrictions on charitable assets. It is thus advisable to address these matters in the plan and confirm the transaction's legal effects under both states' laws. Contracts, grants, licenses, insurance policies, and property records should also be reviewed to identify any required notices, consents, or updates.

The newly domesticated nonprofit should be positioned to continue operations without interruption once all required filings and approvals are effective. Since the corporation will be governed by its new state's nonprofit law, a careful review of its bylaws is also warranted. Registration to do business, charitable solicitation registrations, and periodic reporting obligations should also be reassessed wherever the nonprofit remains active, including its former home state.

With respect to the nonprofit's federal tax-exempt status, IRS Revenue Procedure 2018-15 generally allows qualifying nonprofit corporations to retain IRS recognition of exemption after a domestication without filing a new exemption application. Key requirements include that the organization be recognized as exempt under Section 501(c) and in good standing in its original state, remain a domestic entity classified as a corporation for federal tax purposes, continue the same exempt purposes. Note too that obtaining a new employer identification number (EIN) may or may not be warranted, based on a careful evaluation with legal counsel about accompanying tax and associated operational aspects. For continued Section 501(c)(3) tax-exempt qualification, the new corporate articles must continue to satisfy the applicable IRS organizational test including dedication of its assets to exempt purposes.

Additionally, the written plan of domestication and related records should document related corporate continuity and compliance with applicable state and federal requirements. The nonprofit must also report the restructuring on any required Form 990 and report address changes as prescribed by the IRS. State and local property and sales tax exemptions must be evaluated separately, as federal recognition does not automatically establish those exemptions.

Summing Up

Nonprofit corporate domestication can offer a practical way for a nonprofit to align its state of formation with its current operations and future activities. But changing the state of incorporation involves a foundational corporate modification, not just a mere change in office location, and it is not necessarily worth the time, effort, and financial resources involved. Accordingly, before proceeding with a corporate domestication, nonprofit leaders should carefully consider the goals at hand, operational changes over time, whether the move will meaningfully benefit the organization, whether both contemplated states permit domestication, and other potential options such as to simply continue registration and filing required reports in multiple states.  Evaluation of resulting governance, tax, and ongoing compliance obligations is an important must as well.  With careful planning and appropriate documentation, domestication can allow a nonprofit to “change its stars” without starting over from scratch.

‍

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.